Sunday, February 14, 2010

Building stability in India-Pakistan relations

Note: The following Op-ed appeared in The Hindu on February 15, 2010. The Hindu Op-ed carries the Joint Declaration adopted by the India-Pakistan Track-Two Dialogue (Chaophraya Dialogue) attended by Indians and Pakistanis. This is the forth meeting in an ongoing dialogue process between the two countries held in Bangkok. The earlier dialogues were:

o Conference I: ‘Confidence Building Measures between India and Pakistan’, in Bangkok on 30-31 March, 2009

o Conference II: India-Pakistan Composite Dialogue, in Bangkok, Thailand, on 2-3 October 2009

o Conference III: Building Stability in South Asia, in Bangkok, Thailand, on 8-9 February, 2010.

Following is the text of the decleration as carried by The Hindu and the list of participants.

Building stability in India-Pakistan relations

Senior former officials (including Ambassadors, Foreign Secretaries, Intelligence Chiefs and top-ranking members of the Armed Forces), academics, journalists and political leaders from India and Pakistan conducted a comprehensive two-day dialogue in Bangkok, Thailand, on February 8-9 on a range of issues impacting on the relationship. Terrorism, Jammu and Kashmir, hydro-resources, Afghanistan and nuclear stability were some of the issues discussed.

Welcoming the decision by the two governments to resume the official bilateral dialogue at the Foreign Secretary level, participants at the Chaophraya Dialogue agreed to the following:

1. Peace between and stability in India-Pakistan relations is essential for the well being of South Asia. After nearly 63 years of hostility between India and Pakistan, it is critical that all stakeholders work for sustainable peace between the two countries. Civil societies in India and Pakistan, by and large, support the goal of peace and reconciliation; peace constituencies in both countries must, therefore, be further strengthened by providing them greater space and support. It is essential that the trust deficit and the burden of history not be allowed to impact on the task of moving relations forward.

2. Trust can be best built through multiple uninterruptible dialogues, positive incremental steps, Confidence and Trust-building Measures, and most critically through acts of statesmanship by the leaders of the two countries.

3. A grand reconciliation can only be ensured, in the long-term, through engagement at every level: civil society meetings, official dialogues, engagement of political leaders, cooperation between business and corporate leaders, visits of artists, sportsmen, media, talks between the armed forces, Track II engagements, etc.

4. Temporary setback in inter-governmental relations should not be allowed to impinge on people-to-people cooperation. Attempts should be made to create a visa-free regime for important stakeholders: including academics, journalists, businessmen, students, artists and former senior officials.

5. Progress made in previous rounds of talks should be carried forward in the official dialogue.

6. Terrorism is of deep concern to India and Pakistan. The memory of the Mumbai attacks is still alive and continues to inform public opinion in India. Today, terrorism and extremism pose an existential threat to Pakistan. Indian concerns about terrorism and the terrorist threats to India are as much of a serious concern for Pakistan. Terrorism and extremism need to be comprehensively and permanently defeated.

7. India and Pakistan should seriously consider initiating an institutionalised, regular but discreet dialogue between the intelligence chiefs (the heads of R&AW, IB and ISI and IB Pakistan) of both countries.

8. The back channel on Jammu and Kashmir must be resumed at an early date keeping in view the fact that all stake-holders, particularly the people of J&K, will have to be consulted at some stage. If Jammu and Kashmir is considered as a piece of real estate there is little hope of a way ahead. Therefore, the welfare of the people of Jammu and Kashmir must be considered to be of paramount concern. In this context, all agreed CBMs must be more robustly implemented.

9. The media are playing a critical role in shaping popular perceptions. They have thus a great responsibility to help strengthen the constituency for peace. A continuing dialogue between journalists, editors and proprietors of media houses is needed.

10. A sustained dialogue on ensuring strategic stability in South Asia must be an essential part of the bilateral dialogue. There is also need for discussion amongst experts on critical doctrinal issues and the need to work towards creating a Nuclear Safety, Assistance and Collaboration Regime in the region within the framework of minimum deterrence. In this context, a trilateral nuclear dialogue which includes China must also be pursued.

11. The problem of water is becoming a matter of great concern and there is a need to address misperceptions in this regard. The Indus Water Treaty has withstood the test of time and has a well established dispute-settlement mechanism. Any concern about hydro-resources of the Indus river system should be taken up through the Permanent Indus Water Commission. Within the framework of the treaty, the two countries must also share best practices on water management with each other. Environmental and other experts with domain knowledge, from both countries, must be encouraged to provide concrete recommendations for better and optimal management of hydro resources given the huge challenge that the scarcity of water will pose for the region in the future.

12. A stable, prosperous, sovereign and independent Afghanistan is in the interest of India and Pakistan and both countries must work for this goal and hold talks to allay each other’s apprehensions.

13. Track-II dialogues are designed to move beyond officially stated positions, find a way forward, and can provide alternative approaches to the governments of Pakistan and India as well as other important stakeholders. It is vital that Track II dialogues be encouraged by both New Delhi and Islamabad.

Pakistani participants: Samina Ahmed, South Asia Project Director at the International Crisis Group, Gen. (retd.) Ehsan ul Haq, former Chairman, Joint Chiefs of Staff, Amb. Aziz Ahmad Khan, former High Commissioner of Pakistan to India, Gen. (retd.) Aziz Mohammad Khan, former Chairman, Joint Chiefs of Staff, Amb. Humayun Khan, Foreign Secretary of Pakistan, Amb. Riaz Khokhar, Foreign Secretary of Pakistan, Amb. Rustam Shah Mohmand, former Ambassador of Pakistan to Afghanistan, and Sherry Rehman, Member of Parliament

Indian participants: Maj. Gen. (retd.) Dipankar Banerjee, Director, Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies, A.S. Dulat, former Director, Research and Analysis Wing, Sagarika Ghose, senior editor and prime time anchor, CNN-IBN, Happymon Jacob, Assistant Professor, Centre for International Politics, Organization and Disarmament, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Amitabh Mattoo, Professor, Centre for International Politics, Organization and Disarmament, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Rear Adml. (retd.) Raja Menon, Chairman, Task Force on Net Assessment and Simulation, National Security Council, Amb. G. Parthasarathy, former High Commissioner of India to Pakistan, Vikram Sood, former Director, Research and Analysis Wing, Siddharth Varadarajan, Strategic Affairs Editor and Chief of National Bureau, The Hindu.

(Source: The Hindu, February 15, 2010. URL: http://beta.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/article106611.ece)

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Is peace possible between India and Pakistan? Sir, what is your opinion?

HAPPYMON JACOB said...

Of course, it's a matter of time before the two countries make peace. The question is not whether but when.

Anonymous said...

In the Sat Yug or Golden Age, there will be no war or borders anywhere on Mother Earth before 21 December 2012 for sure!

Please kindly sign and urgently inform your friends of 3 exciting new and important Whitehouse petitions on "We The People" on President Obama's website at

PETITION 1

https://wwws.whitehouse.gov/petitions/!/petition/announce-and-implement-national-economic-security-and-reformation-act-nesara/GrQ0cm26 .

PETITION 2
https://wwws.whitehouse.gov/petitions#!/petition/immediately-disclose-governments-knowledge-and-communications-extraterrestrial-beings/bGWkJk9Y

PETITION 3
https://wwws.whitehouse.gov/petitions#!/petition/formally-acknowledge-extraterrestrial-presence-engaging-human-race-disclosure/wfYDlmlG

The implications of these petition are huge on the whole Universe. Not only is it important that President Obama implements the NESARA law (National Economic Security & Reformation Act 2000), but explains why it was not implemented at 10am on 11 September 2001. It means that the federal reserves will be redistributed to all the people of the world, all governmental land would be returned to the people, all taxation on essential goods would cease and all debts would be forgiven. Paper money will be replaced by precious metals.

As a way of background, the White Knights were the farmers in the USA, who as Second World War veterans were given vast land for farming. The Government then started forcing the farmers off the land, the farmers went to court and proved that under the US laws, the Government had no rights to own land. The NESARA law was passed on 09 March 2000 by Bill Clinton but it was subjected to a gagging order under penalty of death. The matter was brought before the World Court and again the farmers won and the gag was lifted and the NESARA law was signed by 183 countries.

With these petitions, people from all over the world have a unique opportunity to support international implementation of the 11 year old NESARA law and release thousands of patents of free energy devices and health sonar machines.

The NESARA announcement will be followed by a formal announcement of benevolent extraterrestrial presence or “Angels”. Although the CIA had secretly built 1400 huge underground cities deep under the ground, all over the world, in association with the malevolent extraterrestrials (the bad guys), the Galactic Federation of Love & Light (Benevolent Extraterrestrials or “Angels” or the “good guys”) halted all secret experiments in two of the main ones recently. The message is clear, no more places left for any evil to hide.
Please, kindly, give attention to this most urgent matter and sign the above three petitions and pass them all to your contacts, networks and media.
If you need more background, read people like Benjamin Fulford, http://benjaminfulford.net/ David Wilcock, http://divinecosmos.com/, Dr Steven Greer http://www.disclosureproject.org/ .
History: http://pathwaytoascension.wordpress.com/2011/08/17/history-of-nesara
Background :
http://2013rainbowroundtable.ning.com Tara & Rama
www.ashtarontheroad.com see archives for channelled messages from the Galactic Federation