STATECRAFT BY HAPPYMON JACOB
General (retd.) Pervez Musharraff has been a controversial man – both as a soldier and politician. Today, I would like to reflect about him in the larger context of how Pakistan has treated its politicians including the soldiers-turned-politicians. History is witness to the fact that Pakistan has not treated its politicians fairly and accorded them the dignity they deserve: while many Pakistani politicians – Zulfikar Ali and Benazir Bhutto and Zia-ul Haq included – faced violent deaths, some of them were thrown out of their elected office (Bhutto, Shariff et. al.), and some others have criminal charges pending against them. Musharraff himself survived a number of assassination attempts, have criminal cases pending against him in Pakistani courts and was indirectly forced out of office. Today, he is unable to return to Pakistan and his political legacy is questioned and challenged by even those who stood by him during his heydays. The Pakistani political system has a tendency to vilify their leaders.
I am no supporter of Musharraff. In fact, I think his time is over and it is perhaps best for him not to return to Pakistan. After all, in politics, time is everything. One of the reasons why I would like to write this piece about him is because of my recent visit to Munich to attend the Munich Security Conference (MSC). The meeting was attended by over 400 participants including Hillary Clinton, John McCain, US Defense Secretary, many Prime Ministers, Defense and Foreign Ministers from around the world. I saw Musharraff twice, seated in the 5th or 6th row like an ordinary participant. Someone, one of his staff members I guess, approached me thinking that I was a Pakistani participant and told me that the German and international media covering MSC was not giving any importance to the former President and that I should do what I can to get him more media attention. Of course, I had neither the resources nor the willingness to do anything about it. But then that’s not the point of this story. This was a complete contrast to 2005 when I had met him in his office in Islamabad. I was very impressed by his ideas about Kashmir and way he visualized Indo-Pak relations. Musharraff, then, was at the pinnacle of his regime and was indeed one of the most sought-after leaders in the region. He was courted by the Americans, the Europeans and was thought of even by the Indians as the man who could bring peace between the two nuclear rivals.
Musharraff is a much troubled former military dictator today. His return to Pakistan is uncertain. He is likely to be arrested and tried for a number of cases pending against him in Pakistan. While on the one hand, the major political parties in the country would consider him as an absolute anathema, there is no popular mood in support of him either. Even Imran Khan, who Musharraff thought of allying with, has refused to do so. Musharraff apparently has no political ally left in the country. Pervez Musharraff is a much unwanted man in Pakistan’s siasat today.
What about his ideas and initiatives on conflict resolution? Will the embattled leader’s ideas, especially the ones relating to India in general and Kashmir in particular, survive the political downturn that his legacy is witnessing in the country today? Well, no one seems to be sure of that. No one wants identity with him and his ideas especially when it is not sure whether or not he is returning to Pakistan and what will happen to him if he does return. Even those who were close to him have been saying that they have no knowledge of whatever he said or did.
Understandably, this is not liked by a lot of people in Kashmir for they had not only appreciated the Musharraff formula for Kashmir but had also pinned their hopes on him and his formula to get a better political deal for them. Although in today’s Pakistan not everyone is very happy to endorse Musharraff’s ideas, the fact is that the rethinking he began about India and Kashmir in Islamabad is not all over. Many actors, including political parties, may be willing to accept his formula if New Delhi pushes for it but without the ‘Musharraff tag’ attached to it.
Musharraf was an accepted Pakistani leader in New Delhi while he was in power and his ideas on Kashmir had a lot of takers here. When negotiating with him, New Delhi was willing to downplay his legacy of Kargil for the sake of reaching an amicable solution on Kashmir. However, the mood in New Delhi seems to have changed and a lot of people here now prefer to remember him as the architect of Kargil - which he is – not as the Pakistani leader India negotiated the longest and most successful peace process with.
The rise and fall of Musharraf holds significant lessons for democracy, peace processes and especially for a potential political solution to the Kashmir conflict. However, what is important for us is to keep in mind that although we may or may not like the political careers or political lives of some of our political leaders, we must not malign their good deeds or emancipatory political ideas they pursued with vision.
(Source: Greater Kashmir, 12 FEBRUARY 2012, URL: http://greaterkashmir.com/news/2012/Feb/12/pervez-musharraff-rise-and-fall-30.asp )
COMMENTS:
Dr. Jacob's recommendations are based on a western rationale, which presupposes fuctionability and integrity of CBMs and risk management institutions. An existential institutional asymmetry (a representative government in India, and military in control of nuclear assets in Pakistan) between the two countries nullifies such rationale. Any amount of agreements between the two rival governments, will come to naught unless this asymmetry is removed. A classical example of dubiousness in Pakistani establishment's stance to agreements is the discovery of Osama Bin Laden's presence in Pakistan's heartland. Inspite of multifarious military and strategic understandings with their biggest benefactor (the United States) over the years, their establishment was found cheating. Expecting same establishment to honor track-II agreements and CBMs, is a little far fetched in my opinion.
The declared and undeclared nuclear doctrines of both Pakistan and India are of no consequence in the event of a war. Both countries can renounce their doctrines as and when required. The declared and undeclared nuclear doctrines of China follow the same path. China is the first country to declare that they will not use WMD first. The Chinese military threat is the tilting point in the event of a war between India and Pakistan. It is important to resolve the border issues with China so that the Chinese nuclear threat is not of future concern. Yet, the conventional military threat of China with or without war between India and Pakistan cannot be ignored. The Chinese intervention, in the event of a war between Pakistan and India, can overwhelm the Indian defense capability, though India can overcome the conventional military of Pakistan. In the event of a nuclear war between India and Pakistan, there will not be a winner, both countries will be loosers.
We must give up our policy of no-first-use doctrine,which pakistan
has not adopted, in order to counter the pak strategy and we must be
ready 24*7 to deter the pakistan in case of any possible nuclear
attack on us. Its the need of the hour to augment our efforts to develop technology to effectively detect the nuclear submarines,radars and such other nuclaer armed missiles by upgrading our defence R and D the global
standards.
I have pity for people like this author and India's stratgists. The naked truth is this that Pakistan has no policy on any issue. Their credibility is zero and I want anyone to challenge me on the fact that there is not even a single treaty/agreement signed with Pakistan which was not violated by the latter or Pakistan did not allege that India violated the treaty. Look at the violations of ceasefire by Pakistan, repeated exposure of their duplicity on terror not only by India but by their allies, Simla agreement, Nuclear proliferation. I might come across as a Pakistan basher but have a look to what is happening to pledges/agreements signed between different institutions of Pakistan. These talks will lead us nowhere. India must prepare itself for the worst case scenario, rather than, relying on Pakistan to keep its word. Also see the fate of 26/11 accused case. It is a huge challenge to deal with Pakistan.
Lot of arm chair generals commenting. Regardless of stated doctrine, both are rational enough to realize that a nuclear war, even if you don't get nuked is a disaster for all of South Asia. I actually pity the ones who would survive the blasts, it would be a living hell. Imagine just one nuke on top of the Indus and Ganges. These sustaining natural wonders will turn to death streams polluting the soil that feeds a population of over 1.5 billion humans.
In pespective of China and USA,these two countries are mere toys.Till they settle such talks have no meaning.Irony is they will never settle and life goes on in all countries under tension.
"An eye for an eye only makes the world blind" is still relevent here. Rether than first use policy, why not use no use policy and dismantle the arsenal. If Pakistan should choose to use nuclear weapon against India successfully, before the polulation dies away, exhaust all our waste towards the north west and both populations should be taken care of. That is the stupidity of the stances of both governments that if nuclear weapons were to be used, there will be unmitigated disaster on our hands. The semantics of who uses this first will be truly lost as there will be very little left of the glorious civilisation in this region. China is not being strategic either as a huge nuclear expolsion is not going to be too far of chinese inhabitants.
Here is a modern indication for Gandhain principles. Destroy our nuclear arsenal and prove our intention to Pakistan. If they are foolish enough to chuck a few here, well then there will be very few to debate the rights and wrongs then!
Any dialogue, whether an official or track-2, between these two
cultural partners appear nothing more than reiteration of the long
known rhetoric that characterizes these talks "they(Ind. & Pak) can
talk-on-the-table but can't turn-the table."
The deeds and the diplomacy resorted to by both the countries seldom
care about the agreements accepted by them at the table. Taking in
account the skewed political conditions in Pakistan with military,
judiciary, and parliament engaged in long played "hide and seek"
game and classical "blame-game" its quite natural that violations of
the T&Cs often stem from their sides. But India's responses to Pak's
military erection should be more prudent and more responsible
keeping in reckoning it's international stature. After all can we
afford to be as irresponsible as pak, as draconian as China,as
selfish as USA and deaf to our own ethos and appeal of non-violence
and "PANCH-SHEEL".
India and Pakistan War.Shall we call it as a 3rd world war?A World War involving Asia.As endorsed by the Author,the time has come to mull over the consequences of this war if it happens.Surely,the losers will be the pakistanis and the hindustanis,AS Nuclear War is imminent.So,this causality of War and Nuclear War should be dealt internationally.India has always tried to offer an olive branch to the Paks,which the Paks have considered and ascertained as an ACT OF HUMILIATION AND MOCKERY.India has always maintained its NO-FIRST-GO policy and every Indian including me firmly believes this hypothesis.But,Pakistanis have never promised the same and will never do the same.Always ebullient with the support of USA and China ,they always try to instigate the cold relationship into fire.The reason lies behind the cloak of democracy which Paks are wearing.So,internationally some efforts should be entertained.
As a Pakistani, I believe that both countries should renounce their nuclear weapons programs We both have too many malnourished and uneducated people to take care of
is India enough capable to handle situation if pakistan use nuclear
weapoons against us?? What is the role of China in Indo-Pak nuclear unstability?
nice article, but i think author should also have advocated for both the countries to sign CTBT. which can act as one of prominent grounds in CBM to avoid use of nuclear arsenals. Not only it will help in removing the ambiguity but also both nation can send a clear message of non-usage of nuclear bombs/devices during war.