MY TAKE ON DOMESTIC POLITICS, INDIAN FOREIGN POLICY AND INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS
Friday, January 6, 2012
Comparative Foreign Policy Decision Making
Saturday, December 31, 2011
Defining normalcy in Kashmir
STATECRAFT BY HAPPYMON JACOB
What was normal about 2011?
2011 ended with Kashmiris shivering in their homes due to acute power shortages. The state government has been unable to provide a basic necessity such as electricity to the people of Kashmir in sub-zero temperatures. What is even more appalling is that the state bureaucracy and the political class have ‘royally’ (and may I say shamelessly) abdicated their responsibility and shifted base to Jammu where the weather is better, leaving Kashmiris at the mercy of extreme temperatures with no electricity. If the state administrative machinery were to continue to be based in Srinagar, they would at least have tired to make the power situation better.
There has not been any great surge in the development of the state in any sphere in 2011: no new infrastructure development worth mentioning, no sufficient employment generation, and no significant external investment. The dreaded AFSPA has neither been lifted nor amended despite the ruling party’s high-pitched arguments for it and futile grand-standing. Not even once did Kashmir’s ruling party threaten to pull out of the UPA coalition in New Delhi to put pressure on the latter to remove AFSPA from Kashmir. There have been a number of custodial killings and high-handedness by the security forces. Even in 2011 Kashmiris faced the humiliation of having to go through multiple identity checks and unfriendly body frisking by security forces in their own neighbourhood. 2011 also witnessed the still-unraveling story of 2000 odd unmarked graves in Kashmir whose unfortunate occupants and their grief-stricken families still await any form of justice. The Kashmir interlocutors went around in the state talking to various people (excluding, of course, those who matter), wrote an exhaustive report and submitted to New Delhi: not many believe that any action will be taken on the basis of that even as some of the interlocutors claim from time to time that their recommendations are being followed by the government!
Why at least some people tend to call 2011 a peaceful (which literally means ‘full of peace’!) year is because a) as I pointed out above the focus is on what happens to the state and not to the people and, b) because of the problem in the definition of its opposite, violence. When the state defines violence, it takes extra care to address only direct forms of violence and not those indirect and structural forms of violence. Structural violence is widely defined as the “avoidable disparity between the potential ability to fulfill basic needs and their actual fulfillment”. To understand structural violence, one needs t look at mundane things such as availability of electricity, jobs, quality higher education, respect for human rights, ability to live with dignity etc. I don’t need to repeat here the ‘quality’ of human rights protection in the valley! Take another example: Greater Kashmir reported recently that J&K contributes 32% of energy to National Hydroelectric Power Corporation as against 68% by all the other Indian states. And yet, Kashmir seems to suffer from power shortages every winter. Now that’s a form of structural violence, isn’t it?
Normalcy for whom?
Who does the “Kashmir is normal” argument benefit? The ruling dispensation, the Chief Minister and, of course, New Delhi. Claims about Kashmir’s return to normalcy increase the star power of the Chief Minister and makes him even more of a darling of the elite English media in Delhi, it sells New Delhi’s pet story of “Kashmir’s normalization” which it has been choreographing for some time now, and of course the Indian army which can now take pride in the fact that they have ‘defeated’ terrorism! But does this normalcy story of 2011 make any difference to the average Kashmiri or, at the macro level, does it help resolve the political problem in Kashmir? No. Indeed it is true that there was a reduction in the instances of direct violence against Kashmiris in 2011. This opportunity, however, should have been used by the powers that be to address the other entrenched forms of violence rather than busying themselves in fantasizing about the imagined return of normalcy into the Kashmir valley. In short, 2011 will be remembered as a year that was wasted due to the lack of credible, courageous and visionary political leadership.
Saturday, December 17, 2011
Hypocrisy of Kashmir’s alcohol debate
STATECRAFT BY HAPPYMON JACOB
Whether or not alcohol and cinema should be allowed in
However, let me begin by saying that it does not take a great deal of intelligence to understand that Farooq Abdullah is clearly engaging in a customized version of ‘diversionary war tactic’ to divert the undue attention from his party’s failure at removing AFSPA from J&K in spite of being a partner of the ruling coalition in New Delhi. Moreover, liquor and cinema are not the burning problems of today’s Kashmir; there are surely other more pressing issues to be dealt with in
And yet, I maintain that those opposing the ‘re-introduction’ of films and alcohol into the
Why opponents of cinema and alcohol are wrong
Some critics of the proposed re-introduction of films and liquor in Kashmir have suggested that it is a ploy of the government to push the normalcy argument about Kashmir, i.e., that popular forms of entertainment and free availability of commodities such as liquor will help create an image of Kashmir as a normal place which, consequently, will encourage the government to forget about the political resolution of the Kashmir conflict. This is a flawed argument. Consider this. After the 2008 elections, in which Kashmiris voted in large numbers, many in Srinagar and New Delhi tired to paint a picture of normalcy but the massive uprisings in Kashmir thereafter rendered such arguments about election-induced normalcy in Kashmir completely wrong. This means that trappings of externally-induced normalcy are unlikely to work in
When Dukhtaran-e-Millat, Hurriyat Conference (G) and Jamaat-e-Islami toe a particular political line, there is every reason to be suspicious. Look at the core argument that they seem to be making: “
More so, indeed paradoxically, the Hindu communalists and upholders of the Islamic state in
More importantly, it is necessary to remember that
When the sale of alcohol was allowed in
Moreover, in a liberal society it is impossible and undesirable to decide choices for everyone by using religious arguments or even secular arguments. All that we should do is to educate our children and instill good values in them rather than trying to make choices for them all their lives.
Finally, is it not a ridiculous argument that films represent and promote vulgarity? Some might, but most of them do not. Did 'Inshallah, football' represent vulgarity? Does interaction among sexes promote social degradation? Does the use of facebook/twitter/orkut and internet in general negatively influence people and promote vulgarity in society? They may, or may not. And at the end of the day how a medium is used, for vulgar or decent purposes, depends upon the attitudes of the person.
(Source: Greater
Sunday, November 27, 2011
India’s New Kashmir Narrative
STATECRAFT BY HAPPYMON JACOB
I am increasingly of the opinion that the Indian – not necessarily
The first new actor that I would like to identify as having acted as a catalyst, in more ways than one, in transforming the Indian approach to
New Identities
looked at Bollywood films to understand the portrayal of
(Source: Greater
Sunday, November 6, 2011
In the name of AFSPA
Of a political establishment that does not have the courage to make up its mind on such a crucial issue!
STATECRAFT BY HAPPYMON JACOB
Theatre of the Absurd
The various claims, counterclaims, half-truths, and thoughtless pronouncements on the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA) in
Omar’s hide and seek
Chief Minister Omar Abdullah recently claimed that AFSPA would be lifted partially from
Games the Congress Plays
The Congress Chief in the state, Saifuddin Soz, is outraged that Omar had not consulted anyone prior to stating that AFSPA would be withdrawn from parts of the state. Soz accused Omar of promoting sectarian interests and not consulting the state cabinet or the NC-Congress Coordination Committee on the issue. He is right and yet that is just a half truth. Are we supposed to believe that Saifuddin Soz is unhappy with Omar Abdullah for not consulting his party regarding the withdrawal of AFSPA? That would be absurd. The real endgame behind the ongoing war of words is the Congress’ desire to take over the Chief Ministership of the state from Omar as they did so in 2005 after dethroning Mufti Mohammad Sayeed. Since Ghulam Nabi Azad has had his stint as the Chief Minister of the state and seemingly not focused on the state at the moment, it’s the turn for Soz to try his luck. Hence his talk about ASFPA aims to, a) pit Omar Abdullah against the security establishment in
The military in
I can not but agree with the wise words of M. M Ansari, the low-profile
Anarchy at the helm
Apparently the Prime Minister, the Union Home Minister, the J&K Chief Minister and the J&K opposition leader are all in favour of withdrawing AFSPA, partly or fully, from
(Source: Greater
Saturday, October 22, 2011
Pakistan’s New Kashmir Policy
STATECRAFT BY HAPPYMON JACOB
Those of us who attended the 6th and 7th Chaophraya track-two Dialogues on Indo-Pak relations (October 16-19, 2011) in Bangkok were in for a surprise when leading strategic thinkers and media representatives from India and Pakistan started discussing the ever so contentious ‘K’ issue. One retired senior official from the
This was not a lone view coming from a retired Pakistani official; others from the Pakistani contingent seemed to be either toeing a very moderate line on Kashmir (in comparison to
The Pakistani climb-down on the core issue of Kashmir was coupled with an increasing focus on
Deconstructing the new Pakistani stand on
So what do we make of
Let’s return to the question what explains the new Pakistani policy shift on
I don’t think anyone has any obvious answers to these questions. It’s most likely that the perceptible change in
Sunday, October 2, 2011
"Harud: In Memoriam"
STATECRAFT BY HAPPYMON JACOB
The stupidity of the Organisors
The organisors of ‘Harud-The Autumn Festival of Literature’ displayed utmost ignorance and stupidity – and I do not wish to mince words here – when they declared that the festival would be an apolitical forum and later when they decided to cancel it. First of all, if literature is to do with society, emotions, culture, life, impressions etc., how on earth can it be apolitical? Isn’t ‘apolitical literature’ an oxymoron, to say the least? If the organisors of the Jaipur Literature Festival consider literature to be an apolitical affair, they have no right to engage in anything to do with literature: they are at best corporate event managers of glitzy literary outputs if they think they are engaging in an apolitical act. Hence, if Harud was intended to be organized along the lines of a flashy corporate event, it’s better that we don’t have it because politics lies at the heart of literature.
The norm-setters of the society have told us that educational institutions are and should be apolitical, but are they and should they be? We probably have the finest and most informed political debates happening in our university and college campuses. I have, over the last decade or so, gained more political knowledge from the post-dinner public meetings conducted in JNU’s mess halls than from any clinically written textbooks of politics. They say classrooms are and should be apolitical, but are they and should they be? I teach issues relating to national security at JNU and every lecture I give at JNU’s School of International Studies ends up becoming a discussion/debate about the politics of national security.
The organisors also cited potential protests at the site of the festival as a reason for canceling the event. But what did they expect? Did they expect that Kashmir is as calm as the Dal Lake and that there would be no security threats and protests? Did they think that since the Indian state has tried to silence the Kashmiris for so long, they would be an obedient group of passive individuals who would say no more than what was required of them?
Why the opposition to Harud was misconceived
The organisors of the Harud Festival are stupid, why buy their stupidity? If claiming that a literary festival is an apolitical affair is stupid, then protesting against that stupid comment to the extent to making the organisors to refuse to host the much needed event in Kashmir is not wise either. While political criticism is, for sure, social service, critiquing something for the sake of it and/or then not doing anything alternative or parallel to rectify the mistakes is irresponsibility.
More so, was Harud indeed an attempt by the Indian state’s propaganda machine to paint the picture that all is well in Kashmir? The Indian government has of course tried to “normalize” Kashmir for many decades. It purchased local politicians, pumped thousands of crores of rupees into the state, micromanaged and manipulated politics there, and its policies led to the deaths of thousands of Kashmiris. But have all these attempts by the Indian state managed to stop the dissenting Kashmiris? No. Have these attempts by New Delhi convinced us that all is well in Kashmir? No. Did the misplaced sense of triumphalism in Srinagar and New Delhi regarding the ‘victory of democracy and the defeat of dissent’ in the Valley witnessed after the 2008 State Assembly elections stop the Kashmiris from taking to streets in protest against the killings of innocent Kashmiris in the summer of 2010? No. Did the visit of the Pakistani rock-band Junoon in May 2008 and their performance at the Dal Lake give us a feeling that all is well in Kashmir? No.
Had Harud been organized in Srinagar as per schedule, would it have meant that all is well in Kashmir and moreover would it have been a victory for the Indian state in Kashmir? No. Was the proposal to hold Harud in Kashmir by a non-governmental organization a conspiracy of the Indian state to paint an “all is well” picture of Kashmir? No.
Whose loss is it anyways?
At the end of the day, when the intellectual dust generated by the debates surrounding Harud settles down, we will need to ask ourselves an important question: who has lost most from the cancellation of the Harud festival? For sure, it’s a loss for art, for the young aspiring artistic-minded kashmirs and their youthful dreams, and most importantly, for our levels of tolerance. I wonder why it is that the intellectuals and writers who voiced their opinion loud and clear against holding Harud in Kashmir kept mum when some protesters there threatened that they would do anything to stop a particular person from coming to Kashmir to attend Harud. Don’t they believe in artistic freedom? Didn’t we hear them cry foul when the Hindutwa fundamentalists publicly posed death threats to late M. F. Hussain for his anti-Hindu paintings? Why is there a double standard?
(Source: Greater Kashmir, October 2, 2010. URL: http://www.greaterkashmir.com/news/2011/Oct/2/harud-in-memoriam-4.asp )